Bayplan

NAS or cloud storage: which costs less?

Cloud storage is rented by the month and the rent never ends. A NAS is bought once and sits in your house. Which is cheaper depends on one number: what you pay now.

Start there.

Best-seller ranks checked on Amazon UK on 11 Nov 2026. Specs are the makers’ own.

Amazon buttons are ads. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Boxes are not ranked by commission. How this site makes money

Add up your cloud bill

Type what you pay each month for iCloud, Google, Dropbox or OneDrive storage. This adds it up.

a month

On iCloud+? Tap your plan

Over how long?

Your total appears here. Nothing you type is saved or sent anywhere.

The plan prices are Apple’s UK iCloud+ prices on 16 Nov 2026. The total is your bill × 12 × the years, nothing more. To be fair to the cloud: a NAS uses a little electricity, drives wear out in the end, and you should still keep one copy of the things you can’t replace somewhere else.

When the NAS wins

Your bill keeps climbing. Phones shoot more video every year, and cloud plans come in big steps. Apple’s UK iCloud+ plans go from 200 GB straight to 2 TB, then to 6 TB and 12 TB (checked 16 Nov 2026).

Several people share it. One box backs up every phone and laptop in the house.

You want the files at home. Your photos sit on drives you own, on your own network.

When the cloud wins

Your bill is small. If you pay a pound or two a month, a NAS will not pay for itself. Keep the plan.

You don’t want a box to look after. A NAS needs drives, a place near the router, and the odd update. The cloud needs nothing.

It is your only copy. The cloud keeps your files in a building that is not your house. A NAS on its own does not.

Most people end up with both

The NAS holds everything: every photo, every video, every backup. A small cloud plan, or a drive kept at a relative’s house, holds a second copy of the things you could never replace. The two drives in a NAS protect you from a dead drive. They do not protect you from fire, theft or deleting the wrong folder.

The box most homes leaving the cloud should buy

UGREEN DH2300

No.1 best seller in NAS on Amazon UK when we checked on 11 Nov 2026

The first NAS most homes should buy: two bays for phone, photo and file backup, run from UGREEN’s app on iPhone, Android, Windows or Mac.

Good for

  • A first NAS for phones, photos and files
  • Getting off a monthly cloud storage bill
  • A shelf or a cupboard: two bays and one network cable

Think twice

  • One 1GbE network port, which limits how fast big files copy
  • 4 GB of memory, fixed: it can’t be upgraded later
  • Two bays give you one drive’s worth of protected space
Bays
2
Processor
Rockchip RK3576 · 8-core
Memory
4 GB
Network
1 ×
Drives
2 × 3.5″ / 2.5″
Software

For a big library or lots of video

UGREEN DH4300 Plus

Four bays, kept simple. The same UGREEN software as the DH2300, with twice the memory and a 2.5GbE port.

Good for

  • A bigger photo and video library, or backups for a whole family
  • About three drives’ worth of protected space from four drives
  • Docker apps (UGREEN says it runs Docker, but not virtual machines)

Think twice

  • 8 GB of memory, fixed
  • No virtual machines
Bays
4
Processor
Rockchip 8-core · A76 + A55
Memory
8 GB
Network
1 ×
Drives
4 ×
Software

Then add drives

A NAS arrives empty. Buy drives made for NAS use: rated to run all day, and marked CMR. Price them before you choose a box: for a small NAS the drives can cost more than the box itself.

In a two-bay box the second drive mirrors the first, so you get the space of one. In a four-bay, one drive’s worth is kept back for protection and you get about three. A UPS is a battery that gives the box time to shut down safely in a power cut.

The WD Red Plus button opens one product page with a size picker. The other two open Amazon UK searches.

Questions people ask

Why don’t you show what the NAS costs?
Prices on Amazon change daily and a stale one is worse than none. The sum above shows your side of it; each button opens today’s price so you can compare the two yourself.
Don’t forget the drives.
Quite. A NAS arrives empty, and for a small box the drives can cost more than the box. Price both before you decide.
Does a NAS cost anything to run?
A little electricity, all day. We don’t quote a figure because it depends on the box and the drives in it; the makers’ spec sheets give theirs.
How big a box do I need?
That depends on how much you store. The planner works it out from one number on your phone or computer.

Not sure how much space you need? Size it from what you store. It takes about a minute.