Bayplan
How a NAS works, lesson 3 of 7. About 3 minutes.

Four bays and the spare-drive trick

The short version

Four drives give you three drives of space, and any one of the four can still die.

A mirror spends half of what you buy on protection. With four drives there is a cleverer arrangement: keep one drive’s worth of protection, and use the other three for files. Its technical name is .

The surprising part is that the protection isn’t a copy. Four 8 TB drives hold 24 TB of files, and still any one of the four can die without losing a thing.

Drive 1A1B1C1D spareDrive 2A2B2C spareD1Drive 3A3B spareC2D2Drive 4A spareB3C3D3

Each row is a slice of your files: three pieces of data and one spare piece of protection, on a different drive each time. Four drives, three drives’ worth of space. Pull any one out.

Fig. 1. Four drives. Each row holds three pieces of your files and one spare piece. Pull any drive out, then pull out a second.

How one spare stands in for any drive

It is the same trick as this.

Tap any drive to lose it.

Fig. 2. Three numbers and their total. Lose any one of the four and it can be worked out from the other three. A NAS does this with the ones and noughts of your files instead of sums.

The catches

Refilling a drive is slow. After you swap a dead drive, the box has to work out everything that was on it. On large drives that takes many hours, sometimes more than a day.

A second failure in that time loses everything. This is the real risk of a big set of drives, and it is why exists: two drives’ worth of protection instead of one.

Buy all four the same size. In a plain RAID 5 the smallest drive sets the limit for all of them.

Do you need four bays?

Only if you have a lot to store. Our planner moves you from two bays to four when your plan crosses 12 TB. The RAID calculator does the sum for any number of drives.

The kit for four bays

  1. A four-bay box

    UGREEN DH4300 Plus. Four bays, kept simple. The same UGREEN software as the DH2300, with twice the memory and a 2.5GbE port.

    Or the same size from the other maker, on Synology DSM:

  2. 4 NAS drives, all the same size

    The box arrives empty. Buy drives made for NAS use, marked CMR.

    The WD Red Plus button opens one product page with a size picker. The other button opens an Amazon UK search.

  3. A UPS

    A battery that gives the box time to shut down safely in a power cut. UGREEN sells this box with one: the DH4300 Plus with a UPS (ad)

    UPS for a NAS on Amazon UK

Amazon buttons are ads. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Boxes are not ranked by commission. How this site makes money